Bundling for piece of mind
Stakeholders
Toolkit
In the competitive realm of online travel agents (OTAs), Travix, operating under five distinctive sub-brands (Cheapticket, Vliegwinkel, Budgetair, Vayama, and Flugladen), embarked on a pivotal journey. Faced with the ever-evolving travel market, through business expectations and data analysis our mission was clear: to enhance the user experience and empower our customers with the ability to effortlessly purchase a variety of travel-related products, all while unlocking significant discounts and savings.

The challenge
The challenge at hand revolved around our need to effectively reintroduce and promote 'peace of mind' products, akin to those offered by our competitors in 'flexibility' bundles. While our rivals seamlessly presented these bundled offerings alongside flight ticket selection, we faced the significant issue of users bypassing these options when initially presented, particularly on the Search Results page.
This problem was of paramount importance due to several key factors:
User Experience: Users were missing out on valuable features, such as luggage level selection, flexible date options, AirHelp+ for disruption and luggage coverage, and a third party comprehensive cancellation protection product called Cancel for any Reason. We needed to ensure that these options were not only available but also seamlessly integrated into the user's decision-making process.
Business Impact: The omission of these ancillary products directly impacted the bottom line. Specifically, AirHelp+, a third-party product, had previously demonstrated a remarkable 4x increase in revenue when introduced in a similar format on other Online Travel Agencies (OTAs). Failing to address this challenge meant missing out on a significant revenue opportunity.
Overview
Our competitors have a significant lead in 'flexibility' bundles and have already established/tested these products in front of live users. Generally on their sites/apps, when customers selected their flights, they were presented with the choice to opt for bundles during the early stages of the booking process.
In our case, however, the challenge lay in the event where the customer did not initially select the flexible bundle option during their initial interaction, often presented on the first page of the Checkout process. The challenge became how to reintroduce and offer these 'piece of mind' products throughout the remainder of the booking process in a manner that seamlessly integrated with the user's decision-making process.
The primary goals of this project were threefold:
Enhance the user experience by consolidating 'piece of mind' products in one place within the booking flow, ensuring a seamless integration into the user's decision-making process.
Improve the satisfaction of price-conscious users by offering discounts and savings through bundled product offerings.
Increase the conversion rate for specific ancillary products.
The success of this project was not only pivotal for enhancing user satisfaction and experience but also for aligning with our overarching business objective of expanding our market share in the competitive European market over the next three years. To address the scale and complexity of this challenge, we needed a strategic approach that involved collaboration and coordination among diverse stakeholders across business units, teams, and roles. As a result, the project was thoughtfully incorporated into our product roadmap for a two-quarter implementation beginning in early 2023.

The process
We embarked on a comprehensive design process rooted in experience design and design thinking methodologies. This journey consisted of several critical phases, each contributing to the refinement of our solution.
The discovery phase
The define phase
The refine phase
The build phase
Live A/B testing
Data analysis
Continual optimisation and improvement
Our design decisions were guided by the principle of enhancing the user experience and addressing the identified problem. We recognised that visibility and appeal were paramount. By integrating these offerings into the user journey, users could easily understand the value and make informed decisions. The selection and positioning of the products must be carefully considered to ensure a seamless experience that would improve user satisfaction and ultimately lead to an increase in conversion rates for ancillary products.
This design process, rooted in experience design & design thinking, allowed us to approach the problem systematically, incorporating user insights and iterative testing to ensure our solution was user-centric and effective. It also fit how Travix operates from a product and development perspective.

Discovery
The process began with a deep dive into understanding the problem and its context by looking at the market and our users with their behavioural patterns, technological constraints we needed to design around and also our stakeholders along with any other organisational risks.
We gathered insights from conducting competitive analysis, and examined existing internal user data to comprehend why users were bypassing these valuable 'peace of mind' products. This initial phase helped us frame the problem and uncover critical pain points.
The output of this phase was a lot of sticky notes that we needed to make sense of in the next phase.

Defining
From the output of the Discovery phase we needed to synthesise the raw notes, ideas and observations into a series of concepts that we could further synthesise and iterate on, until a clear idea of the product emerged. The start of this phase was very ambiguous but by the end we had a clear understanding of what the solution would be to appeal to the user and meet their needs.
Workshops were held by the Agile coaches with key stakeholders and players (Design, Data, Engineering and Product) to organise and digest the information gathered, then brainstorm potential solutions. The output of the workshops fed the next stage.

Refining
In this iterative phase we took the general direction established within the Define phase and transformed it into a single cohesive design. Our refinement started with more focus exploration of potential executions at a low fidelity and plotting their exposure points so we could assess if they fit naturally within the local real estate (page).
As the Lead Designer, I tasked different designers to concentrate on specific explorations i.e. matrix style, card style and wild card designs. This gave us the breadth of design thinking we needed to approach the problem from different angles.
These low fidelity designs were put through bi-weekly design critiques with fellow designers and a weekly design feedback session with the main stakeholders (Product Owners, Engineering Leads & Lead Data Analyst). This ensured continual engagement from stakeholders and an agreed solution that was comprehensive, even though the design was not yet fleshed out to high fidelity and complete for the MVP release into A/B experiment.

Building
Working closely with the engineers and those implementing the experience, in this phase we focused on the details, communication, and validation. We achieved this by fleshing out the agreed designs, documented and communicated our design decisions to a wider audience and validated the designs through user testing a rich prototype.
Also, this was the perfect point in the project to align with the Experimentation team to assign the KPIs that we would use to measure it’s success (or failure) when it was released into an A/B experiment.
This phase was the longest and it extended not only through implementation but through the subsequent iterations as well.

The result
The extensive effort invested in enhancing the user experience and reintroducing 'peace of mind' products into the booking flow had a substantial positive impact on our key performance indicators (KPIs). Below, you can see both qualitative and quantitative results to demonstrate the success of this project.
Quantitative Results
Attach Rate:
Prior to the project, the attach rate for individual 'peace of mind' products were around 5%. Following the implementation of the solution, the attach rate increased by 15%, indicating that users were more inclined to select these ancillary products bundled together earlier in the booking process.Bounce Rate:
Before the project, the bounce rate on the Checkout 0 page, where users were initially presented with 'peace of mind' products, was 45%. After the solution was integrated, the bounce rate decreased by 15%, showing that users were more engaged and less likely to leave the page without taking action.Conversion Rate:
The conversion rate for specific ancillary products, including Luggage options and Cancel for any Reason, improved significantly. Before the project, the conversion rate was around 14% for Luggage and 4% for CFAR. After the project's implementation, the conversion rate increased to around 30% for luggage and 12% for CFAR, highlighting a top end threefold increase in conversion for these products.Contribution Margin Ratio:
The contribution margin ratio for 'peace of mind' products demonstrated substantial growth. The introduction of these products and the increase in conversion rates positively impacted the bottom line. The contribution margin ratio increased by around 5%, contributing to higher profitability for Travix.
Qualitative Results
User Experience Improvement:
User feedback and surveys indicated a significant improvement in the overall user experience. Users praised the seamless integration of 'peace of mind' products, stating that they appreciated having these options available when making their travel decisions. Users reported that they found it easier to understand the value and benefits of these products.Satisfaction of Price-Conscious Users:
Price-conscious users expressed satisfaction with the discounts and savings offered through bundled product offerings. They felt that Travix was providing value-added options without compromising affordability. This feedback reflected positively on the brand and its offerings.Enhanced User Satisfaction:
The overall user satisfaction score increased by 10% after the implementation of the solution. Users were more satisfied with their booking experience, citing the convenience and transparency of the process as a key factor in their satisfaction.
Business Impact
The positive impact on our KPIs and the qualitative feedback from users directly translated into a substantial business impact. The revenue generated from 'peace of mind' products, particularly Luggage and CFAR, increased by 3 times, aligning with the industry standard observed in other Online Travel Agencies (OTAs). This not only improved profitability but also helped Travix secure a stronger position in the competitive European travel market.

The challenges and learnings
Challenges:
Introducing Ancillary Products: The primary challenge was reintroducing and promoting 'peace of mind' products in a way that seamlessly integrated with the user's decision-making process. Users were initially bypassing these options, especially on the Search Results page, which presented a significant challenge.
User Experience Integration: Ensuring that 'peace of mind' products were not only available but also seamlessly integrated into the user's decision-making process posed a major challenge. The goal was to consolidate these products in one place within the booking flow, which required careful design and execution.
Business Impact: The omission of ancillary products directly impacted the company's revenue. Failing to address this challenge meant missing out on significant revenue opportunities, such as the potential increase in revenue observed in other Online Travel Agencies.
Collaboration and Coordination: The scale and complexity of the project required collaboration and coordination among diverse stakeholders across different business units, teams, and roles. Aligning the project with the product roadmap and ensuring buy-in from various stakeholders was a significant challenge.
Multi product display: It became evident that having a matrix style visualisation for the multiple products, so the users can proceed through their decision making process with less friction, was logical on larger screen sizes like tablets and desktop as they have the visual real estate. However, this was a huge UX and UI problem on smaller screen sizes as a matrix design pattern simply does not fit without scrolling and therefore adding user friction rather than reducing it.
Learnings:
User-Centric Design: This case study emphasises the importance of user-centric design. The process involved a deep understanding of user behaviour and preferences, as well as iterative testing to ensure that the solution effectively addressed user pain points and needs.
Data-Driven Decision Making: The project involved the collection and analysis of data to understand user behaviour and to track the impact of the solution. Data analysis was crucial in assessing the success of the project and making informed design decisions.
Iterative Testing and Refinement: The project involved multiple phases of iterative testing and refinement. This approach allowed the team to evolve the solution and ensure that it met the needs of both users and stakeholders.
Effective Collaboration: The success of the project hinged on effective collaboration and coordination among diverse stakeholders. This case study underscores the importance of aligning the project with the product roadmap and maintaining ongoing engagement with stakeholders throughout the design and implementation process.
Quantitative and Qualitative Evaluation: This project used a combination of quantitative and qualitative metrics to assess its success. Quantitative metrics such as attach rate, bounce rate, conversion rate, and contribution margin ratio were used to measure the impact on KPIs, while qualitative feedback from users provided insights into their satisfaction and experience.
Revenue Growth: This project demonstrated the potential for substantial revenue growth by addressing user needs and preferences. Learnings include the importance of identifying revenue opportunities within the user experience.
UI limitations: In rare occasions like this project, compromise needs to be made in order to get the feature to market. In our case the normal responsive mobile first pattern did not fit our solution and 2 variants were created to handle the limitations of small screen sizes.
These challenges and learnings highlight the complexity of the project and the strategies employed to address them effectively.

The future
To continue improving the feature in the future, it's important to build on the success of the initial project and further enhance the user experience while maximising the revenue potential of ancillary products. Here are some recommendations for future improvements:
User Feedback and Iteration:
Continue to gather user feedback through surveys, user testing, and user behaviour analysis. User feedback is invaluable for identifying pain points, preferences, and areas for improvement. Use this feedback to iterate on the design and functionality of the feature.Personalisation:
Explore the potential for personalisation based on user preferences and behaviours. Tailor the presentation of ancillary products to individual users, offering them the most relevant options. This can enhance user satisfaction and conversion rates.A/B Testing and Experimentation:
Maintain a culture of experimentation and A/B testing. Test different variations of how 'peace of mind' products are presented and integrated into the booking flow. Continually monitor the impact on key metrics and make data-driven decisions.Mobile Optimisation:
Given the importance of mobile devices in the travel booking process, ensure that the feature is optimised for mobile platforms. The user experience on mobile devices should be as seamless as on desktop.Dynamic Pricing and Promotions:
Implement dynamic pricing strategies that offer discounts and promotions to users, especially those who may be price-sensitive. This can incentivise users to choose bundled products and increase attach rates.Educational Content:
Provide users with informative and educational content about the benefits of 'peace of mind' products. Use tooltips, pop-ups, or dedicated sections to explain the advantages and coverage offered by these products. Transparency can improve user understanding and trust.Integration with Loyalty Programs:
Consider integrating the feature with loyalty programs or frequent flyer programs. Offering additional benefits or discounts to program members can encourage loyalty and repeat bookings.Continuous Monitoring and Reporting:
Maintain a system for continuous monitoring and reporting of KPIs. Set up automated dashboards to track attach rates, bounce rates, e-conversion rates, and contribution margin ratios. Regularly review these metrics to identify any signs of decline or areas for further improvement.Competitive Analysis:
Keep an eye on industry trends and competitive offerings. We could stay agile and adapt the feature to remain competitive in the online travel services market. Benchmark against competitors to ensure our offerings are on par or better.Data Security and Compliance:
Ensure that the feature complies with data security and privacy regulations. This is especially important as we collect sensitive user information during the booking process.Customer Support and Assistance:
Provide easy access to customer support and assistance for users who have questions or concerns about ancillary products. Offering a clear channel for support can alleviate user apprehension.Promotion and Marketing:
Implement marketing strategies to promote the value and benefits of 'peace of mind' products. This could include email campaigns, targeted advertising, and in-app notifications to remind users of these options.International Expansion:
Travix operates in multiple markets, we could consider tailoring the presentation of ancillary products to the specific needs and preferences of users in different regions. Localisation can enhance user engagement.
By implementing these recommendations and maintaining a user-centred, data-driven approach, we can further enhance the feature and ensure its ongoing success in improving the user experience and generating revenue for Travix.

Conclusion
In summary, the project successfully achieved its objectives of enhancing the user experience, increasing conversion rates for ancillary products, and aligning with Travix's overarching business goals. The collaboration and coordination among diverse stakeholders, along with the systematic design process, were instrumental in realising these positive results. This project has not only improved user satisfaction but also positioned Travix for sustained growth in the dynamic online travel services industry.


